Gunnedah Shire Council has reversed its September decision and will display four flags in its chamber, after a community campaign and a heated debate over Deputy Mayor Rob Hooke’s comments. Several councillors bristled as speakers and fellow councillors made it clear his remarks had caused offence.
Councillors voted five to four on Wednesday, 18 November, to amend the flag policy so the Australian, NSW, Aboriginal, and Torres Strait Islander flags are displayed permanently along the rear wall of the chamber dais. They will fly at equal height, in order of precedence, and the policy will be implemented as a matter of priority.
The vote overturns an amendment passed in September on the mayor’s casting vote, which would have limited the chamber to the Australian flag alone. The amended draft then went on public exhibition, closing on Wednesday, 14 October.
At the September meeting, Deputy Mayor Hooke said he feared reconciliation could go too far and lead to “a reverse type of apartheid”. He also said the chamber should not represent “special interest groups” referring to Aboriginal people and made a number of other manifestly racist remarks. The community’s reaction to the was visceral, with some heated debate and an organic rising of community action. Council received three petitions with a combined 475 signatures calling for the Aboriginal flag to be displayed in the chamber and relevant areas around the township, and four flags t-shirts were made for people to wear their protest.
Two women also spoke eloquently and passionately on the subject directly to council.
“These flags provide a shared symbol of recognition,” said Gamilaroi woman Kirralee Natty, the first to speak on the policy.
“Recognising one person’s identity does not diminish another’s.”
“There is a contradiction in suggesting that displaying our flags creates segregation, whilst then supporting a policy that would prevent them from ever being displayed.”
“Exclusion does not create inclusion.”
Vanessa Hodges Schembri addressed council next and took Deputy Mayor Hooke’s comments on directly. She told councillors her ancestors included a convict and free settlers, and that her family now has many cultural backgrounds.
“Your comments suggesting that Aboriginal people were special interest groups were offensive,” she said.
“Aboriginal people are not special interest groups. They are this nation’s first people, and they deserve your respect.”
Ms Hodges Schembri said his reference to flags from African and Asian countries was “perhaps a badly worded attempt at suggesting that if we let one race in, then we let them all in”.
“This is also offensive,” she said.
“You do not have the permission of the people in this community who have a multicultural story to use them to do harm to our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community, or to imply that they are lining up demanding representation.”
Cr Kate McGrath, who moved the motion, told the chamber that council had a duty under workplace safety law to prevent racism. She referred to “quite offensive comments” from Deputy Mayor Hooke, who was chairing the meeting, which caused a significant reaction in the chamber and led to protestations from councillors about how they are not racist.
“Any decision I make today is not intended to be racist,” said Cr Juliana McArthur, who voted against the motion.
“It’s not intended to cause harm, and I really resent the inference that anybody who votes against this motion is doing just that.”
Deputy Mayor Hooke said he took offence at being called a racist.
“I am very concerned that it is creating a division in this community,” he said. “We have one flag. We are one nation.”
Cr McGrath replied that she had not called him a racist.
“I did not, in fact, call you a racist. I said your comments were offensive,” she said. “They’ve offended people. That’s all there is to it.”
Those who had supported Cr Hooke’s motion in September to banish the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander flags from the chamber seemed to be surprised by the community reaction,
Cr Tammey McAllan, who voted against, said she had faced abuse over the issue.
“Since this was introduced, I have had nothing but hatred towards me in regards to being racist,” she said.
“In this chamber, everyone is considered equal, no matter who you are.”
Mayor Colleen Fuller also voted against.
“I’ve never seen such division as what I’ve heard in the last couple of months, and I’m absolutely disappointed,” she said.
After the meeting, Cr McGrath thanked all in the community who had made their views heard.
“Thank you to everyone who reached out to tell us how important this decision is in honouring our commitment to Reconciliation, and creating unity within the Gunnedah community,” she wrote.
Like what you’re reading? Support New England Times by making a small contribution today and help us keep delivering local news paywall-free. Donate now
